Comprehending geometry proofs: A study on prospective mathematics teachers' perceptions and preferences of proof formats

The explicative aim of this research is to investigate the optics of proof format preferences held by prospective mathematics teachers (PMTs), in an effort to assess the effect that such preferences may have on their understanding of geometric proofs. The researchers employed a qualitative case study approach, in which six PMTs participated in Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) on the three styles of proof: paragraph proof, two-column proof and flow-chart proof. The methodology employed also focused on the formatting models by exploring the participants’ suggestions regarding each format in order to determine their cognitive responses as well as their preferences. The study exposes different preferences among PMTs which are a result of their personal cognitive style and experience with proofs. Some of the PMTs preferred the two-column format due to its systematic and logical nature, other PMTs preferred the storytelling nature of the paragraph proof format sponsored also flow-chart representation. These preferences bring out the requirement for the development of pedagogical strategies that employ different proof formats in order to meet the needs of different types of learners for effective understanding. In summary, this research demonstrates the need for customizing proof instruction to different students’ needs which can hopefully enhance PMTs’ responses and interactions with the concept of mathematical proofs. The practical outcomes show that teachers should not be afraid to think in more flexible witnessing forms of proof in order to aid students learning while minimizing the cognitive load in line with the principles of constructivist learning. It would be worthwhile however to extend this research and examine what these preferences would mean for the future and how those would fit within the context of online education with the overall aim of creating a better mathematics curriculum that is more effective and has a wider reach.