The Ecotoxicity of Pesticides Used in Conventional Apple and Grapevine Production in Austria Is Much Higher for Honeybees, Birds and Earthworms than Nature-Based Substances Used in Organic Production

It is debated whether the ecotoxicity of active substances (ASs) contained in synthetic pesticides applied in conventional agriculture (conASs) differs from nature-based ASs used in organic agriculture (orgASs). Using the official pesticide use statistics, we evaluated the ecotoxicity of ASs used in apple and grapevine production in Austria. In 2022, 49 conASs and 21 orgASs were authorized for apple production and 60 conASs and 23 orgASs were authorized for grapevine production in Austria. Based on the latest publicly available data on the actual use of pesticides in apple and grapevine production (from the year 2017), we evaluated their ecotoxicity based on information in the freely accessible Pesticide Properties and Bio-Pesticides Databases. The results showed that although the amount of ASs applied per hectare of field was higher in organic farming, the intrinsic toxicities of ASs used in conventional farming were much higher. The number of lethal toxic doses (LD50) of ASs applied in conventional apple orchards was 645%, 15%, and 6011% higher for honeybees, birds, and earthworms, respectively, than in organic apple production. In conventional vineyards, lethal doses for honeybees, birds, and earthworms were 300%, 129%, and 299% higher than in organic vineyards. We conclude that promoting organic farming would therefore contribute to the better protection of biodiversity on agricultural land and beyond.