Comparing Human Performance on Target Localization in Near Infrared and Long Wave Infrared for Cluttered Environments

In the context of rapid advancements in AI, the accuracies and speeds among various AI models and methods are often compared. However, a basic question is rarely asked: is AI better than humans, and if so, under what conditions? This paper investigates human ability to detect distant landmark targets under cluttered surroundings such as buildings, trees, and clouds in NIR and LWIR images, aiming to facilitate AI object detection performance analysis. Our investigation employs perception tests and a human performance model to analyze object detection capabilities. The results reveal distinctive differences in NIR and LWIR detectability, showing that although LWIR performs less effectively at range, it offers superior robustness across various environmental conditions. Our findings suggest that AI could be particularly advantageous for object detection in LWIR as it outperform humans in terms of detection accuracy at a long range.