Applying a Comprehensive Model for Single-Ring Infiltration: Assessment of Temporal Changes in Saturated Hydraulic Conductivity and Physical Soil Properties

Modeling agricultural systems, from the point of view of saving and optimizing water, is a challenging task, because it may require multiple soil physical and hydraulic measurements to investigate the entire crop cycle. The Beerkan method was proposed as a quick and easy approach to estimate the saturated soil hydraulic conductivity, Ks. In this study, a new complete three-dimensional model for Beerkan experiments recently proposed was used. It consists of thirteen different calculation approaches that differ in estimating the macroscopic capillary length, initial (θi) and saturated (θs) soil water contents, use transient or steady-state infiltration data, and different fitting methods to transient data. A steady-state version of the simplified method based on a Beerkan infiltration run (SSBI) was used as the benchmark. Measurements were carried out on five sampling dates during a single growing season (from November to June) in a long-term experiment in which two soil management systems were compared, i.e., minimum tillage (MT) and no tillage (NT). The objectives of this work were (i) to test the proposed new model and calculation approaches under real field conditions, (ii) investigate the impact of MT and NT on soil properties, and (iii) obtain information on the seasonal variability of Ks and other main soil physical properties (θi, soil bulk density, ρb, and water retention curve) under MT and NT. The results showed that the model always overestimated Ks compared to SSBI. Indeed, the estimated Ks differed by a factor of 11 when the most data demanding (A1) approach was considered by a factor of 4–8, depending on the transient or steady-state phase use, when A3 was considered and by a practically negligible factor of 1.0–1.9 with A4. A relatively higher seasonal variability was detected for θi at the MT than NT system. Under both MT and NT, ρb did not change between November and April but increased significantly until the end of the season. The selected calculation approaches provided substantially coherent information on Ks seasonal evolution. Regardless of the approach, the results showed a temporal stability of Ks at least from early April to June under NT; conversely, the MT system was, overall, more affected by temporal changes with a relative stability at the beginning and middle of the season. These findings suggest that a common sampling time for determining Ks could be set at early spring. Soil management affected the soil properties, because the NT system was significantly wetter and more compact than MT on four out of five dates. However, only NT showed a significantly increasing correlation between Ks and the modal pore diameter, suggesting the presence of a relatively smaller and better interconnected pore network in the no-tilled soil. This study confirms the need to test infiltration models under real field conditions to evaluate their pros and cons. The Beerkan method was effective for intensive soil sampling and accurate field investigations on the temporal variability of Ks.