Thoughts on the Beginnings of Psychoanalyses

Musing on the topic of initiating analyses, I began asking myself, what do we experience and what do we mean when we commonly say "an analysis unfolds"? Hans Loewald understood the rhythms of psychic development as <i>coming into being</i>, and that an analysis (when it works) also seems to follow that pattern. This paper will focus on appreciating <i>the new within the old</i> in the analytic process as a way to illustrate narrative and behavioral themes in the analytic dialogue. It will explore how these themes relate to the creativity of analytic unfolding from an initial matrix of psychically overdetermined uncertainties. Analyst, supervisor, and patient can all notice and experience shifts of new forms intermingling with the old. This trope will be clinically expanded and examined (1) with materials from a candidate's first analytic case, (2) with a vignette from a seasoned analyst's beginning case; and (3) a Covid-era beginning treatment. A clinical footnote (dubbed by the author's supervisees "The Balsam Sign") describes a nonverbal mime in the office of a new development occurring within the familiar verbal communication, which may signal a patient's readiness to accept a recommendation to begin an analysis.