Investigating the Role of Viruses in the Rapid Decline of Young Apple Trees in High-Density Orchards in New York

A sudden, unexplained decline and collapse of young apple trees on dwarfing and semi-dwarfing rootstocks has been reported across North America over the past decade. Although viruses have been detected in declining trees, no information is available on their potential causal role in the decline phenomenon. To this end, virus-inoculated apple trees were established in a high-density experimental orchard and monitored over five years. Tree decline was observed in year 4 (2022), resulting in 17% mortality, with declining trees exhibiting marked vascular tissue necrosis. However, none of the eight viruses and one viroid detected in the experimental orchard was significantly more prevalent in declining trees. Extreme temperature fluctuations in January 2022, followed by a severe water deficit in summer 2022, were recorded at the experimental orchard. Similar but distinct observations were made in a nearby commercial orchard with foliar nutrient imbalances documented in trees exhibiting symptoms of rapid decline. Together, our findings suggest that viruses are not primarily responsible for the rapid decline phenomenon and highlight the need for future work to investigate the roles of tree physiology and water stress in tree decline, as well as the potential efficacy of horticultural mitigation practices.