Sampling Confined Fission Tracks for Constraining Geological Thermal Histories

Fission-track modeling rests on etching, counting and measuring the lattice damage trails from uranium fission. The tools for interpreting fission-track data are advanced but the results are never better than the data. Confined-track samples must be an adequate size for statistical analysis, representative of the track population and consistent with the model assumptions and with the calibration data. Geometrical and measurement biases are understood and can be dealt with up to a point. However, the interrelated issues of etching protocol and track selection are more difficult to untangle. Our investigation favors a two-step protocol. The duration of the first step is inversely proportional to the apatite etch rate so that different apatites etch to the same Dpar. A long immersion reveals many more confined tracks, terminated by basal and prism faces. This allows consistent length measurements and permits orienting each track relative to the c-axis. Long immersion times combined with deep ion irradiation reveal confined tracks deep inside the grains. Provided it is long enough, the precise immersion time is not important if the effective etch times of the selected tracks are calculated from their measured widths. Then, whether the sample is mono- or multi-compositional, we can, post hoc, select tracks with the desired properties. The second part of the protocol has to do with the fact that fossil tracks in geological samples appear to be under-etched compared to induced tracks etched under the same conditions. This should be assumed if the semi-axes of a fitted ellipse plot above the induced-track line. In that case, an additional etch can increase the track lengths to a point where they are consistent with the model based on lab-annealing of induced tracks, a condition for valid thermal histories. Here too, it is possible to select a subset of tracks with effective etch times consistent with the model if the widths of confined tracks are measured along with their lengths and orientations.