A Thermodynamic Comparison of the Exergy Production from Sugarcane and Photovoltaic Modules in Brazilian Energy Transition Context

This article applies the exergy analysis to the production and use of sugarcane, considering a model published in the literature. In this way, we compute incident solar irradiation, carbohydrate production, water consumption, and the production of stalks and straws. Following the production estimate, we analyze a biorefinery production cycle, from solar irradiation to the biorefinery products on an exergy basis, from birth to production of sugar, electrical energy, and ethanol. The calculated sugarcane production values are 80.7 tons per hectare for a 52-week cycle. As a result, the average exergy efficiency of sugarcane is 4.99%, reaching peaks of 8.3%. When considering only the useful exergy generated in the production of stalks and straw, an annual yield of 17.86 kWh/m2 represents an overall exergy efficiency of 1.31%. Considering the energy conversion processes in the biorefinery, the exergy efficiency from the radiation to the products from the biorefinery was 0.38%. The photovoltaic modules already have a well-established application in the country, though they need to increase their insertion over time, whereby the panels exhibit an average exergy efficiency of 31.6%, resulting in an annual electrical energy production of 255.84 kWh/m2. The results show that photovoltaic modules are a more efficient alternative than sugarcane regarding exergy land use. In conclusion, this study briefly discusses the use of sugarcane and photovoltaic modules in the context of Brazil’s energy transition towards a reduced dependence on fossil fuels, based on the fact that sugarcane already has a low carbon footprint for transportation using ethanol, with supply from more than 40,000 stations, and a similar or lower carbon footprint than electrical vehicles used across the country.