Characterizing Students’ Identification of Reflection Planes in Inorganic Chemistry Symmetry Tasks

This communication builds on prior research describing how the orientation of a molecular representation can impact student thinking about molecular symmetry. To further support this claim, we present evidence that molecular orientation can impact students’ thinking about reflection planes and reflection operations. We tasked students with performing a reflection operation on a series of planar and nonplanar molecules, each presented in two different orientations. We found that while some students were consistent in the reflection plane they chose across the different orientations, others identified different reflection planes. These findings suggest that students’ analyses of molecular representations should not be considered stable with respect to the orientation of the representation. Implications of this work are framed in the context of the complex manifold of students’ cognitive resource activation patterns and the dependency of those activation patterns on the nature of the task at hand.