Fluorescent sphalerite rich in tungsten, copper, gallium, silver, and other elements from the Cordilleran-style, polymetallic veins of Philipsburg, Montana

• Philipsburg is a Cordilleran-style, polymetallic, porphyry-lode deposit. • Some – not all − sphalerite is strongly fluorescent under long-wave UV light. • Fluorescent sphalerite has low Fe content and is formed at a high sulfidation state. • Trace elements with + 1, +3, +4, and + 6 valence enter ZnS by coupled substitution. • Tungsten concentrations up to 1980 mg/kg exist in bright red fluorescent bands. • High-W sphalerite shows a systematic shift in Raman spectra peaks. Sphalerite from the central, high-sulfidation zone (enargite-stable) of the Philipsburg polymetallic mining district, southwest Montana, displays unusually bright fluorescence (red, orange, yellow, blue, purple, green) under longwave UV light (365 nm). LA-ICP-MS analysis reveals the fluorescent sphalerite has very low Fe (average < 100 ppm) and variable content of other trace elements that correlate to luminescence color banding. Mean/maximum content (in ppm) in fluorescent sphalerite for selected elements are 5.7/7900 Ag, 107/11800 As, 1400/4730 Cd, 917/30400 Cu, 381/5000 Ga, 32/696 Ge, 119/2130 In, 230/8190 Mn, 43/3000 Pb, 16/1700 Sb, and 89/1980 W. This study is the first to document elevated tungsten content (>10 ppm) in sphalerite. Copper is closely correlated with Ga, consistent with the coupled substitution: Cu + + Ga 3+ = 2Zn 2+ . Similar coupled substitution reactions can be written for Ag + , In 3+ , As 3+ , Sb 3+ , Bi 3+ , and Ge 4+ . However, the brightest red fluorescent bands are most closely related to the unexpected presence of W. Sphalerite with high Cu and Ga but lacking W fluoresces yellow and shows a single Raman peak at 349 cm −1 corresponding to pure sphalerite. In contrast, red-fluorescent sphalerite shows the presence of a second peak at 427 cm −1 that increases in intensity with increased W content. We propose that tungsten enters the sphalerite lattice as W 6+ via a substitution such as W 6+ + 4Cu + = 5Zn 2+ and that this substitution creates lattice strain that results in the anomalous fluorescence and Raman signals. Sphalerite bands with low concentrations of Cu and Ga fluoresce blue or green. Vivid blue fluorescence is displayed by sphalerite with high Cd (>1000 ppm) but low concentrations of all other trace elements. Sphalerite from the low-sulfidation peripheral mines of the Philipsburg district contains high Fe (>10,000 ppm) and does not fluoresce. Nonetheless, this sphalerite is also highly enriched in trace metals, including Ag (mean 2480/max 8660 ppm), Cu (1610/3440), Mn (7020/8100), and Sb (1960/6390). The results of this study underscore the importance of including tungsten in the list of analytes in future studies of trace elements in sphalerite. In addition, a hand-held UV lamp may be a rapid and cost-effective method to screen sphalerite of variable composition in outcrop or drill core. It may be a useful exploration tool to vector towards a high-sulfidation zone of a zoned porphyry or epithermal deposit, when it is present.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Ore Geology Reviews
Published
2024-09-30
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2024.106267
Citations
1
Primary Topic
Geological and Geochemical Analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.53
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Fluorescent sphalerite rich in tungsten, copper, gallium, silver, and other elements from the Cordilleran-style, polymetallic veins of Philipsburg, Montana

Heather Lowers, Celine Beaucamp, J. M. Thompson, Christopher H. Gammons
1 citations
Ore Geology Reviews
Geological and Geochemical Analysis
0.53
article

Fluorescent sphalerite rich in tungsten, copper, gallium, silver, and other elements from the Cordilleran-style, polymetallic veins of Philipsburg, Montana

Heather Lowers, Celine Beaucamp, J. M. Thompson, Christopher H. Gammons
article en
1 citations

Abstract

• Philipsburg is a Cordilleran-style, polymetallic, porphyry-lode deposit. • Some – not all − sphalerite is strongly fluorescent under long-wave UV light. • Fluorescent sphalerite has low Fe content and is formed at a high sulfidation state. • Trace elements with + 1, +3, +4, and + 6 valence enter ZnS by coupled substitution. • Tungsten concentrations up to 1980 mg/kg exist in bright red fluorescent bands. • High-W sphalerite shows a systematic shift in Raman spectra peaks. Sphalerite from the central, high-sulfidation zone (enargite-stable) of the Philipsburg polymetallic mining district, southwest Montana, displays unusually bright fluorescence (red, orange, yellow, blue, purple, green) under longwave UV light (365 nm). LA-ICP-MS analysis reveals the fluorescent sphalerite has very low Fe (average < 100 ppm) and variable content of other trace elements that correlate to luminescence color banding. Mean/maximum content (in ppm) in fluorescent sphalerite for selected elements are 5.7/7900 Ag, 107/11800 As, 1400/4730 Cd, 917/30400 Cu, 381/5000 Ga, 32/696 Ge, 119/2130 In, 230/8190 Mn, 43/3000 Pb, 16/1700 Sb, and 89/1980 W. This study is the first to document elevated tungsten content (>10 ppm) in sphalerite. Copper is closely correlated with Ga, consistent with the coupled substitution: Cu + + Ga 3+ = 2Zn 2+ . Similar coupled substitution reactions can be written for Ag + , In 3+ , As 3+ , Sb 3+ , Bi 3+ , and Ge 4+ . However, the brightest red fluorescent bands are most closely related to the unexpected presence of W. Sphalerite with high Cu and Ga but lacking W fluoresces yellow and shows a single Raman peak at 349 cm −1 corresponding to pure sphalerite. In contrast, red-fluorescent sphalerite shows the presence of a second peak at 427 cm −1 that increases in intensity with increased W content. We propose that tungsten enters the sphalerite lattice as W 6+ via a substitution such as W 6+ + 4Cu + = 5Zn 2+ and that this substitution creates lattice strain that results in the anomalous fluorescence and Raman signals. Sphalerite bands with low concentrations of Cu and Ga fluoresce blue or green. Vivid blue fluorescence is displayed by sphalerite with high Cd (>1000 ppm) but low concentrations of all other trace elements. Sphalerite from the low-sulfidation peripheral mines of the Philipsburg district contains high Fe (>10,000 ppm) and does not fluoresce. Nonetheless, this sphalerite is also highly enriched in trace metals, including Ag (mean 2480/max 8660 ppm), Cu (1610/3440), Mn (7020/8100), and Sb (1960/6390). The results of this study underscore the importance of including tungsten in the list of analytes in future studies of trace elements in sphalerite. In addition, a hand-held UV lamp may be a rapid and cost-effective method to screen sphalerite of variable composition in outcrop or drill core. It may be a useful exploration tool to vector towards a high-sulfidation zone of a zoned porphyry or epithermal deposit, when it is present.

Ore Geology ReviewsVol. 173
United States Geological Survey (US), Montana Technological University (US)
Openalex Percentile: Top 34%
Geological and Geochemical Analysis
0.53
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.