Different origins of magnetic disturbances during substorm growth and expansion phases and insufficiency of the AL index as their sole measure

The paper examines the relationship between the PC index, characterizing the solar wind energy input into the magnetosphere, and the AL index, characterizing the magnetic substorm intensity for the expansion phase of isolated substorms recorded in 1998–2017. Magnetic disturbances in the course of the expansion phase are produced by the DP11 current system with a powerful westward electrojet disposed in the midnight auroral zone. It is generally accepted that this electrojet is generated by the “substorm current wedge” system of fieldaligned currents (SCW FAC) providing closure of the magnetotail plasma sheet currents through the auroral ionosphere. As this takes place, magnetic disturbances in the course of the substorm growth phase are produced by the DP12 current system with westward and eastward electrojets located, correspondingly, in the morning and evening sectors of the auroral zone, with the electrojets generated by the R1/R2 FAC system operating in the inner (closed) magnetosphere. The intensity of R1 currents is determined by the “coupling function” E KL , which represents the optimal combination of all geoeffective solar wind parameters affecting the magnetosphere. The DP2 magnetic disturbances generated by the R1 FAC system in polar caps forms the basis for estimating the PC index, which strongly follows the E KL field changes and correlates well with the development of magnetic substorms. Analyses performed in AARI revealed the principally distinctive character of the relationships between the PC index and AL index in the course of the substorm growth (DP12 disturbances) and explosive (DP11 disturbances) phases. The DP12 disturbances, generated by FAC systems in the closed magnetosphere, are developed in strong relation to the PC index. The DP11 disturbances, generated by the SCW FAC system, related to the magnetotail plasma sheet, show quite irregular character of relationship between the PC and AL values: the sudden jumps of the substorm intensity ( ALpeaks ) might occur, time and again, at any value of the PC index and with quite different delay times relative to sudden substorm onset. It means that the processes in the tail plasma sheet, leading to the formation of a “substorm current wedge” are determined by the state of the magnetotail plasma sheet itself. The solar wind influence (evaluated by the PC index) affects but does not control the processes in the magnetotail, unlike those in the inner magnetosphere. It should be noted in this connection that the intensity of magnetic DP12 and DP11 disturbances, observed in the course of the substorm growth and explosive phases, is estimated by a single AL index, in spite of the different origin of these disturbances (R1/R2 and SCW FAC systems). It is necessary to employ two separate indices characterizing DP12 and DP11 disturbances in order to allow for the effects of the solar wind on the processes in the inner magnetosphere and in the magnetotail.