Heterogeneity in Dental Tissue–Derived MSCs Revealed by Single-Cell RNA-seq

Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) are multipotent, progenitor cells that reside in tissues across the human body, including the periodontal ligament (PDL) and gingiva. They are a promising therapeutic tool for various degenerative and inflammatory diseases. However, different heterogeneity levels caused by tissue-to-tissue and donor-to-donor variability, and even intercellular differences within a given MSCs population, restrict their therapeutic potential. There are considerable efforts to decipher these heterogeneity levels using different "omics" approaches, including single-cell transcriptomics. Previous studies applied this approach to compare MSCs isolated from various tissues of different individuals, but distinguishing between donor-to-donor and tissue-to-tissue variability is still challenging. In this study, MSCs were isolated from the PDL and gingiva of 5 periodontally healthy individuals and cultured in vitro. A total of 3,844 transcriptomes were generated using single-cell mRNA sequencing. Clustering across the 2 different tissues per donor identified PDL- and gingiva-specific and tissue-spanning MSCs subpopulations with unique upregulated gene sets. Gene/pathway enrichment and protein-protein interaction (PPI) network analysis revealed differences restricted to several cellular processes between tissue-specific subpopulations, indicating a limited tissue-of-origin variability in MSCs. Gene expression, pathway enrichment, and PPI network analysis across all donors' PDL- or gingiva-specific subpopulations showed significant but limited donor-to-donor differences. In conclusion, this study demonstrates tissue- and donor-specific variabilities in the transcriptome level of PDL- and gingiva-derived MSCs, which seem restricted to specific cellular processes. Identifying tissue-specific and tissue-spanning subpopulations highlights the intercellular differences in dental tissue-derived MSCs. It could be reasonable to control MSCs at a single-cell level to ensure their properties before transplantation.