Effect of production scale on the techno-economic viability and environmental life cycle analysis of lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery

Biorefineries are vital for advancing circular economy and reducing the effects of products fossil fuels derived products on the environment. However, biorefineries often operate at smaller production scales than fossil refineries due to limited feedstock availability, which may be addressed by centralised processing with multiple feedstock sources. Lactic acid (LA) has several industrial applications and is a platform chemical used to produce products like acrylic acid and propylene glycol. The economic and environmental performances of an integrated biorefinery at different production scales, through different levels of feedstock centralization, were investigated, to determine the optimal scale for sugarcane-based LA production. Decreasing values for the minimum selling price (MSP; 1312–849 US$.t −1 ) and increasing internal rates of return (IRRs; 31–64 %) were observed with increasing conversion scales of sugarcane A-molasses. The MSPs decrease from 90 to 450 kt LA .y −1 with small improvements in profitability beyond 450 kt LA .y −1 , as confirmed by stochastic financial uncertainty analysis. In the environmental assessment, a linear increase was observed across all impact categories, mainly due to the added fuel consumption for feedstock transportation. LA production had a GWP100 range of 0.87–0.95 kg CO 2 -eq.kg LA −1 and an abiotic depletion potential of 12–13 MJ.kg LA −1 which increased as the scale increased. In the ozone depletion category emissions of 9.96×10 −8 -1.13×10 −7 kg CFC-11 eq.kg LA −1 comparable to other studies available in literature. Similarly, emission ranges of 1.11–1.17, 0.63–0.66, and 1581–1641 kg 1,4-DB eq.kg LA −1 were obtained in the human toxicity, freshwater and marine aquatic ecotoxicity categories as the scale increased. Environmentally the smallest scale at which transportation of feedstock was avoided (i.e. 90 kt LA .y −1 ) is preferred as opposed to 450 kt LA .y −1 for economic performance. • A-molasses is a competitive feedstock for lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery. • Lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery has an optimum scale around 450 kt.y −1 . • Environmental impacts benefits for large scale centralisation LA facility is mainly affected by transportation requirements. • A compromise between economic and environmental aspects is required in decision making.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Food and Bioproducts Processing
Published
2024-09-27
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fbp.2024.09.020
Citations
15
Primary Topic
Biofuel production and bioconversion
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
2.77

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Effect of production scale on the techno-economic viability and environmental life cycle analysis of lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery

Johann F. Görgens, Janus Louw, Mensah S. Brobbey
15 citations
Food and Bioproducts Processing
Biofuel production and bioconversion
2.77
article

Effect of production scale on the techno-economic viability and environmental life cycle analysis of lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery

Johann F. Görgens, Janus Louw, Mensah S. Brobbey
article en
15 citations

Abstract

Biorefineries are vital for advancing circular economy and reducing the effects of products fossil fuels derived products on the environment. However, biorefineries often operate at smaller production scales than fossil refineries due to limited feedstock availability, which may be addressed by centralised processing with multiple feedstock sources. Lactic acid (LA) has several industrial applications and is a platform chemical used to produce products like acrylic acid and propylene glycol. The economic and environmental performances of an integrated biorefinery at different production scales, through different levels of feedstock centralization, were investigated, to determine the optimal scale for sugarcane-based LA production. Decreasing values for the minimum selling price (MSP; 1312–849 US$.t −1 ) and increasing internal rates of return (IRRs; 31–64 %) were observed with increasing conversion scales of sugarcane A-molasses. The MSPs decrease from 90 to 450 kt LA .y −1 with small improvements in profitability beyond 450 kt LA .y −1 , as confirmed by stochastic financial uncertainty analysis. In the environmental assessment, a linear increase was observed across all impact categories, mainly due to the added fuel consumption for feedstock transportation. LA production had a GWP100 range of 0.87–0.95 kg CO 2 -eq.kg LA −1 and an abiotic depletion potential of 12–13 MJ.kg LA −1 which increased as the scale increased. In the ozone depletion category emissions of 9.96×10 −8 -1.13×10 −7 kg CFC-11 eq.kg LA −1 comparable to other studies available in literature. Similarly, emission ranges of 1.11–1.17, 0.63–0.66, and 1581–1641 kg 1,4-DB eq.kg LA −1 were obtained in the human toxicity, freshwater and marine aquatic ecotoxicity categories as the scale increased. Environmentally the smallest scale at which transportation of feedstock was avoided (i.e. 90 kt LA .y −1 ) is preferred as opposed to 450 kt LA .y −1 for economic performance. • A-molasses is a competitive feedstock for lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery. • Lactic acid production in a sugarcane biorefinery has an optimum scale around 450 kt.y −1 . • Environmental impacts benefits for large scale centralisation LA facility is mainly affected by transportation requirements. • A compromise between economic and environmental aspects is required in decision making.

Food and Bioproducts ProcessingVol. 148
Stellenbosch University (ZA)
National Research Foundation
Responsible consumption and production
Openalex Percentile: Top 9%
Biofuel production and bioconversion
2.77
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.