A Comparative Study of Single-Chain and Multi-Chain MCMC Algorithms for Bayesian Model Updating-Based Structural Damage Detection

Bayesian model updating has received considerable attention and has been extensively used in structural damage detection. It provides a rigorous statistical framework for realizing structural system identification and characterizing uncertainties associated with modeling and measurements. The Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) is a promising tool for inferring the posterior distribution of model parameters to avoid the intractable evaluation of multi-dimensional integration. However, the efficacy of most MCMC techniques suffers from the curse of parameter dimension, which restricts the application of Bayesian model updating to the damage detection of large-scale systems. In addition, there are several MCMC techniques that require users to properly choose application-specific models, based on the understanding of algorithm mechanisms and limitations. As seen in the literature, there is a lack of comprehensive work that investigates the performances of various MCMC algorithms in their application of structural damage detection. In this study, the Differential Evolutionary Adaptive Metropolis (DREAM), a multi-chain MCMC, is explored and adapted to Bayesian model updating. This paper illustrates how DREAM is used for model updating with many uncertainty parameters (i.e., 40 parameters). Furthermore, the study provides a tutorial to users who may be less experienced with Bayesian model updating and MCMC. Two advanced single-chain MCMC algorithms, namely, the Delayed Rejection Adaptive Metropolis (DRAM) and Transitional Markov Chain Monte Carlo (TMCMC), and DREAM are elaborately introduced to allow practitioners to understand better the concepts and practical implementations. Their performances in model updating and damage detection are compared through three different engineering applications with increased complexity, e.g., a forty-story shear building, a two-span continuous steel beam, and a large-scale steel pedestrian bridge.