Stand Alone or Stay Together: An In-situ Experiment of Mixed-Reality Applications in Embryonic Anatomy Education

Where traditional media and methods reach their limits in anatomy education, mixed-reality (MR) environments can provide effective learning support because of their high interactivity and spatial visualization capabilities. However, the underlying design and pedagogical requirements are as diverse as the technologies themselves. This paper examines the effectiveness of individual- and collaborative learning environments for anatomy education, using embryonic heart development as an example. Both applications deliver the same content using identical visualizations and hardware but differ in interactivity and pedagogical approach. The environments were evaluated in a user study with medical students (n = 90) during their examination phase, assessing usability, user experience, social interaction/co-presence, cognitive load, and personal preference. Additionally, we conducted a knowledge test before and after an MR learning session to determine educational effects compared to a conventional anatomy seminar. Results indicate that the individual learning environment was generally preferred. However, no significant difference in learning effectiveness could be shown between the conventional approach and the MR applications. This suggests that both can effectively complement traditional seminars despite their different natures. Our study contributes to understanding how different MR settings could be tailored for anatomical education.