Robustness of the relationship between tropical high-cloud cover and large-scale circulations

High clouds play an important role in climate variations by shading the sun and contributing to the greenhouse effect. It has been suggested that these variations are strongly controlled by atmospheric circulations; however, the relationship between high clouds and circulations in global simulations has been confirmed only for a limited number of general circulation models (GCMs). Increasing our understanding of this relationship requires a more complete dataset of state-of-the-art GCMs. This study quantifies the relationship between high clouds and circulations by spatial and temporal correlation using data from 28 atmospheric GCMs along with a global nonhydrostatic model, a new-type of GCM, and reveals a robust and strong relationship in most models. This study also finds that the sensitivity, which is defined as the slope of the relationship between high clouds and mass fluxes of circulations, is highly model-dependent. This suggests that a similar change of circulations does not guarantee that of high clouds, which could be one reason for the complexity in projecting high-cloud changes due to warming. Moreover, this study confirms in both observation and models that the relationship with circulations is stronger for medium-thickness and thick high clouds than for thin clouds. Furthermore, the relationship between high clouds and circulations is more convincing in near-equatorial regions between 15°S–15°N, the ascending branch of the Hadley circulation, where deep convection is especially active.