Post-OCR Correction with OpenAI's GPT Models on Challenging English Prosody Texts

The digitization of historical documents faces challenges with the accuracy of Optical Character Recognition (OCR). Noting the success of large language models (LLMs) on many text-based tasks, this paper explores the potential of OpenAI's GPT models (3.5-turbo, 4, 4-turbo) on the post-OCR correction task using works from the Princeton Prosody Archive (PPA), a full-text searchable database containing English texts published between 1559 and 1928 on versification and pronunciation. We conduct a comparative analysis across different model configurations and prompt strategies. Our results indicate that tailoring prompts with work metadata is less effective than anticipated, though adjusting the temperature parameter can be beneficial. The models tend to overcorrect works with already good OCR quality but perform well overall, with the best model setup improving the Character Error Rate (CER) by a mean of 18.92%. Additionally, after introducing a preliminary quality estimation step to process texts differently based on their original OCR quality, the best mean improvement increases to 38.83%.