Bayes factors for longitudinal model assessment via power posteriors

Bayes factor, defined as the ratio of the marginal likelihood functions of two competing models, is the natural Bayesian procedure for model selection. Marginal likelihoods are usually computationally demanding and complex. This scenario is particularly cumbersome in linear mixed models (LMMs) because the marginal likelihood functions involve integrals of large dimensions determined by the number of parameters and the number of random effects, which in turn increase with the number of individuals in the sample. Power posterior is an attractive proposal in the context of the Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms that allows expressing marginal likelihoods as one-dimensional integrals over the unit range. This paper explores the use of power posteriors in LMMs and discusses its behavior through three simulation studies and a real data set on European sardine landings in the Mediterranean Sea.