Isotopic fractionation of methane on Mars via diffusive separation in the subsurface

Many processes have been identified in the Martian subsurface which may produce or release methane that eventually can be emitted into the atmosphere. Given the wide range of isotopic values for source carbon reported on Mars and the importance of atmospheric methane isotopologues as a tracer for subsurface processes, it is critical to quantify the level of isotopic fractionation that can occur during subsurface transport. On Earth, isotopic fractionation occurs when methane transport is dominated by Knudsen diffusion through small pores. However, unlike the Earth, on Mars the low atmospheric pressure and commensurate longer mean free path suggest that most subsurface transport of methane occurs in the Knudsen regime, amplifying this effect. Here, we report on simulations of diffusion through the martian subsurface and report on the level of fractionation that would be expected under two end-member scenarios. For Interplanetary Dust Particles (IDPs) incorporated in near-surface sediments in which methane is released quickly upon generation, atmospheric emissions of methane are expected to be representative of the reservoir isotopic ratio. However, for deeper sources in which methane accumulates as trapped gas, subsurface transport will result in depletions of 13 CH 4 compared to reservoir concentrations by approximately −31‰. Over time, both the reservoir and the emitted gas will evolve to become isotopically enriched in 13 CH 4 compared to a standard of constant isotopic ratio. This necessitates temporal measurements of emitted methane to understand the δ 13 C of the reservoir and depth of the release, preferably with hourly or better frequency. Finally, a seasonal cycle in δ 13 C with an amplitude of 5.3‰ is expected with adsorption acting to create small temporary reservoirs that are filled and emptied over the year by the subsurface thermal wave. This effect may provide a way to probe near-surface thermophysical properties. • Knudsen diffusion may be widespread in the martian subsurface causing fractionation. • Atmospheric methane derived from shallow solid sources (IDPs) are likely unaltered. • Atmospheric methane derived from deep sources can be significantly fractionated. • Seasonal isotopic variations can give information about subsurface properties. • High frequency methane measurement is needed to determine source isotopic ratios.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Planetary and Space Science
Published
2024-09-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pss.2024.105971
Citations
1
Primary Topic
Planetary Science and Exploration
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.33

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Isotopic fractionation of methane on Mars via diffusive separation in the subsurface

H. M. Sapers, John E. Moores
1 citations
Planetary and Space Science
Planetary Science and Exploration
0.33
article

Isotopic fractionation of methane on Mars via diffusive separation in the subsurface

H. M. Sapers, John E. Moores
article en
1 citations

Abstract

Many processes have been identified in the Martian subsurface which may produce or release methane that eventually can be emitted into the atmosphere. Given the wide range of isotopic values for source carbon reported on Mars and the importance of atmospheric methane isotopologues as a tracer for subsurface processes, it is critical to quantify the level of isotopic fractionation that can occur during subsurface transport. On Earth, isotopic fractionation occurs when methane transport is dominated by Knudsen diffusion through small pores. However, unlike the Earth, on Mars the low atmospheric pressure and commensurate longer mean free path suggest that most subsurface transport of methane occurs in the Knudsen regime, amplifying this effect. Here, we report on simulations of diffusion through the martian subsurface and report on the level of fractionation that would be expected under two end-member scenarios. For Interplanetary Dust Particles (IDPs) incorporated in near-surface sediments in which methane is released quickly upon generation, atmospheric emissions of methane are expected to be representative of the reservoir isotopic ratio. However, for deeper sources in which methane accumulates as trapped gas, subsurface transport will result in depletions of 13 CH 4 compared to reservoir concentrations by approximately −31‰. Over time, both the reservoir and the emitted gas will evolve to become isotopically enriched in 13 CH 4 compared to a standard of constant isotopic ratio. This necessitates temporal measurements of emitted methane to understand the δ 13 C of the reservoir and depth of the release, preferably with hourly or better frequency. Finally, a seasonal cycle in δ 13 C with an amplitude of 5.3‰ is expected with adsorption acting to create small temporary reservoirs that are filled and emptied over the year by the subsurface thermal wave. This effect may provide a way to probe near-surface thermophysical properties. • Knudsen diffusion may be widespread in the martian subsurface causing fractionation. • Atmospheric methane derived from shallow solid sources (IDPs) are likely unaltered. • Atmospheric methane derived from deep sources can be significantly fractionated. • Seasonal isotopic variations can give information about subsurface properties. • High frequency methane measurement is needed to determine source isotopic ratios.

Planetary and Space ScienceVol. 251
York University (CA)
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
Openalex Percentile: Top 35%
Planetary Science and Exploration
0.33
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.