Beware the Black Widow at Claim Time: A Report of Three Cases

Moral hazard is well known to life insurance underwriters and medical directors to increase the risk of adverse consequences to insured individuals. The underwriting investigation of proposed insureds at time of policy issue is done to ensure no likely moral hazard exists. However, not all situations involving moral hazard may be identified at time of underwriting and policy issue, and may only be identified at time of claim. Three cases that were underwritten for life expectancies in legal matters are described here as examples of moral hazard identified at time of severe injury and/or death. All three of these cases involved a woman who manipulated her male partner into situations that increased the man's risk of severe injury and/or death to the woman's financial benefit. Such "black widows" made a great deal of effort over an extensive period of time to ensure that the moral hazard set up for their male partners resulted in a substantial financial windfall through litigation. The moral hazard set up by a black widow thus can be considered by the life insurance industry as sufficiently anti-selective and speculative to deny a claim at any time after policy issue.