Coarsening of alloy carbides during a cyclic heat treatment for grain refinement in ultrahigh-strength steels

Strength–ductility trade-off dilemma is acute in materials science, especially for ultrahigh-strength steels. The improvement of toughness requires careful tuning of grains and precipitates. Thermal cyclic treatment and annealing before quenching are two effective ways of microstructural refinement for steels. However, a combination of the two methods has never been studied. Complex alloy carbides form in the process of annealing, but their effects on grain refinement in the subsequent quenching are unclear. Here, a systematic comparison of microstructure and mechanical properties is established between a thermal cyclic treatment with annealing (CHT) and traditional quench-temper treatment (QT). The results indicate that the CHT treatment leads to the coarsening of alloy carbides and subgrains, and the decrease in strength and toughness.