The Impact of Fatigue in Foot-Stabilizing Muscles on Foot Pronation during Gait and a Comparison of Static and Dynamic Navicular Drop Assessments

Background: Individuals may exhibit altered foot pronation during gait when fatigue sets in. Therefore, a more evidence-based understanding of these fatigue-induced changes may be helpful for future gait analysis and return-to-play tests since fatigue can provide new insights that might explain a person’s complaints. Methods: A total of 25 healthy individuals (12♂, 13♀; 24.3 ± 2.7 years; 174.9 ± 9.09 cm; 70 ± 14.2 kg; BMI: 22.7 ± 2.8) participated in this controlled non-randomized study of unilateral fatigue of the right foot’s stabilizing muscles with regard to the pronation of the foot, measured by navicular drop (ND) in static (statND; standing) and dynamic (dynND; walking) states. The left foot served as the control. Surface electromyography was used to verify fatigue. Results: While the statND did not change, the dynND increased significantly by 1.44 ± 2.1 mm (=22.3%) after the foot-stabilizing muscles experienced fatigue. No correlation was found between the statND and dynND. Conclusions: Muscular fatigue can affect foot pronation. The dynND appears to be more representative of the loads in everyday life, whereby most studies use the statND.