Novel Perspectives on Chloroplast tRNA Genomic and Structural Variations Imply the Evolution of Papilionoideae (Fabaceae)

Papilionoideae is the most species-rich subfamily of the third largest angiosperm family Fabaceae. One constituent large group, the inverted-repeat-lacking clade (IRLC), is well-known for the broad loss of one IR copy. Accumulating observations of massive plastomic disparities have made IRLC a well-suited model for exploring plastome evolution. However, there is still a large amount left to explore. The present study focused on the plastid tRNA (pttRNA) evolution within Papilionoideae, employing the currently densest sampling strategies for both the IRLC (156) and non-IRLC (109) lineages. Strikingly, our results revealed abundant inter-lineage variabilities in both tRNA sequences and structures, including a 3 nt difference in the average size of trnS-UGA, the consensus sequence disparities across 29 tRNAs, the distinct 3 nt indels in trnA-UGC, and an impressive 248 nt intron loss of IRLC trnI-GAU (potential markers). Additionally, there was unequal stability of the atypical secondary structures in trnS-GGA and trnS-UGA, as well as significantly diverse compositions of substitution events in all compared tRNAs (p < 0.05). Ultimately, these findings not only demonstrate the significant differences and unique markers of IRLC pttRNAs compared to other non-IRLC Papilionoideae, but also draw an important conclusion that the large losses of one IR potentially promote highly diverse evolutionary patterns of IRLC, which could partly compensate for the potential IR-lacking impacts.