A landscape limnology approach to assessing controls on soluble reactive phosphorus in sediment porewater and internal loading risk

Sediment nutrients can be mobilized to overlying water via internal loading, which can be important to aquatic productivity. Using data from 143 Canadian lakes, we show high (~2400-fold) variation of soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) concentrations in surficial sediment porewater, with results suggesting internal phosphorus loading (IPL) is also likely to vary widely. Consistent with past work at smaller scales, we show that lake depth, pH, trophic status, and bulk sediment Al:P and Fe:P influence porewater SRP, and IPL. Median porewater SRP concentration in lakes with high Al:P (molar ratios >10) were 4.8-fold smaller than in lakes with lower Al:P. In lakes where bulk sedimentary Fe:P molar ratios were >10 porewater SRP was 3.9-fold lower than in lakes with lower Fe:P. High pH (>7.8), along with hyper-eutrophic lakes were associated with higher porewater SRP. Finally, shallow lakes (<4 m depth) had median porewater SRP concentration 6-fold higher than deep lakes (>9 m depth). Important regional differences emerged, linked to regional variation in pH, soils, lake depth and trophic status, and paralleling areas of poor water quality. For example, median porewater SRP in lakes from the Boreal Plains and Prairies ecozones (dominated by Chernozems/Mollisols) was 64-fold and 44-fold higher than in the Boreal Shield (dominated by Podzols/Spodosols) (respectively), although we note that IPL risk is likely important across many ecozones. Using national data, we found in-lake measurements (particularly pH, and salinity) showed strong capacity in predicting porewater SRP (explaining 60-72 % of the variance in the data). Importantly, watershed predictors showed good predictive power, explaining ~50 % of variance in porewater SRP using variables including soil types, and % agriculture. Porewater SRP can be predicted with reasonable accuracy using easily measured variables, as can estimates of internal phosphorus loading, suggesting that landscape limnology holds strong potential in helping to inform lake management by informing understanding of in-lake nutrient sources.