Divergent responses of aggregate breakdown by slaking to nitrogen forms in solution for contrasting soil types

Aggregate stability strongly affects many soil processes and is critical to maintain sustainable agriculture. Aggregate breakdown is controlled by the interaction between soil intrinsic properties and solution characteristics. Nitrogen fertilization including different forms is well known to influence aggregate stability; however, relative to their long-term effects, there is little recognition on the rapid response of aggregate breakdown to nitrogen solutions. This study aimed to examine the effects of nitrogen form and concentration on aggregate stability for different types of soils. Aggregate breakdown against slaking of three soil types (Phaeozem, Luvisol, and Acrisol) and three horizons (organo-mineral (A), illuvium (B), and parent material horizons (C)) was determined subjected to nitrogen solutions of three forms (CO(NH2)2, NH4+, NO3–) and five concentrations (0.05 ∼ 1.0 mol/L). Among nitrogen forms, urea solution almost had non-significant effect irrespective of soil type and horizon (p > 0.05); for NH4+ and NO3– solutions, aggregate stability showed little variations (MWD of 0.19 ∼ 0.26 mm) with electrolyte concentration for Phaeozem in B and C horizons, overall increased for Luvisol and Phaeozem in A horizon, and decreased first and then reached a steady state for Acrisol. The effects of nitrogen forms on aggregate breakdown were dependent on soil aggregation status or cementing agents (mainly organic matter, clay mineralogy). Electrolyte nitrogen solutions (NH4+ and NO3–) inhibited aggregate breakdown mainly through reducing electrostatic repulsive forces for moderately developed soils rich in swelling clays, and promoted aggregate breakdown by both weakening particle cohesion and enhancing compression pressure of entrapped air for highly developed soils rich in non-swelling clays and Fe/Al oxides. These results facilitate an improvement of fertilizer management and irrigation to improve soil quality on different soil types.