Viral plasticity facilitates host diversity in challenging environments

The antagonistic coevolution of microbes and viruses influences fundamentally the diversity of microbial communities. Information on how environmental variables interact with emergent defense-counterdefense strategies and community composition is, however, still scarce. Following biological intuition, diversity should increase with improved growth conditions, which offset evolutionary costs; however, laboratory and regional data suggest that microbial diversity decreases in nutrient-rich conditions. Moreover, global oceanic data show that microbial and viral diversity decline for high latitudes, although the underlying mechanisms are unknown. This article addresses these gaps by introducing an eco-evolutionary model for bacteria-virus antagonistic coevolution. The theory presented here harmonizes the observations above and identifies negative density dependence and viral plasticity (dependence of virus performance on host physiological state) as key drivers: environmental conditions selecting for slow host growth also limit viral performance, facilitating the survival of a diverse host community; host diversity, in turn, enables viral portfolio effects and bet-hedging strategies that sustain viral diversity. From marine microbes to phage therapy against antibiotic-resistant bacteria or cancer cells, the ubiquity of antagonistic coevolution highlights the need to consider eco-evolutionary interactions across a gradient of growth conditions.