A Comparative Analysis of U-Net and Vision Transformer Architectures in Semi-Supervised Prostate Zonal Segmentation

The precise segmentation of different regions of the prostate is crucial in the diagnosis and treatment of prostate-related diseases. However, the scarcity of labeled prostate data poses a challenge for the accurate segmentation of its different regions. We perform the segmentation of different regions of the prostate using U-Net- and Vision Transformer (ViT)-based architectures. We use five semi-supervised learning methods, including entropy minimization, cross pseudo-supervision, mean teacher, uncertainty-aware mean teacher (UAMT), and interpolation consistency training (ICT) to compare the results with the state-of-the-art prostate semi-supervised segmentation network uncertainty-aware temporal self-learning (UATS). The UAMT method improves the prostate segmentation accuracy and provides stable prostate region segmentation results. ICT plays a more stable role in the prostate region segmentation results, which provides strong support for the medical image segmentation task, and demonstrates the robustness of U-Net for medical image segmentation. UATS is still more applicable to the U-Net backbone and has a very significant effect on a positive prediction rate. However, the performance of ViT in combination with semi-supervision still requires further optimization. This comparative analysis applies various semi-supervised learning methods to prostate zonal segmentation. It guides future prostate segmentation developments and offers insights into utilizing limited labeled data in medical imaging.