Empowering Medical Students to Practice High-Value Care

Over the last decade, initiatives like the Choosing Wisely campaign have promoted the practice of evidence-based, cost-conscious care. However, education surrounding value in medicine has been largely restricted to graduate-level medical education or post-clerkship undergraduate medical education. Here, we present a mixed-methods study evaluating pre-clerkship medical student engagement with and response to new value-based curricular initiatives to assess whether high-value care (HVC) can be introduced successfully earlier in training. Initiatives were introduced into the pre-clerkship clinical curriculum without major alterations to the established curricular structure. These comprised an annual event devoted to self-reflecting on HVC observed in prior and current clinical experiences and subsequent small-group facilitated discussion. Engagement with and response to these initiatives were analyzed for two whole-class cohorts using an abductive, progressive focusing approach complementing quantitative survey data. Baseline familiarity with HVC and post-event response to the annual event was higher and more positive, respectively, among responders from the Class of 2025 compared with those from the Class of 2024. Analysis of reflection essays revealed the emergence of five primary themes differentiating the two class years: (1) understanding HVC, (2) addressing barriers to HVC, (3) medical waste and underserved communities, (4) patient–physician relationship and value, and (5) self-reflection. Evaluation of thematic patterns in light of survey response data suggests that early clinical exposure combined with intentional self-reflection could promote engagement with HVC topics in a way that shapes students’ foundational understanding of the practice of medicine.