Kyanite microstructural and microchemical characteristics reveal differences in growth, deformation and chemical modification: A case study from the Paleoproterozoic suture zone of South Harris, NW Scotland

Based on petrological association, cathodoluminescence (CL), trace element signatures and orientation relationships, two generations of kyanite are distinguished in a high temperature, high pressure garnet-biotite-aluminosilicate bearing migmatite of South Harris, NW Scotland. The migmatite shows a garnet and biotite rich domain ( Grt-Bt domain) which is cut at a low angle by a dominantly coarse-grained plagioclase-quartz leucosome. In addition, a fine-grained plagioclase-quartz-kyanite domain ( Plag-Qtz-Ky domain ) is present intercalated with the Grt-Bt domain and subparallel to the plagioclase-quartz domain. Type 1 kyanite is coarse grained and associated with Bt clusters and garnet within the Grt-Bt domain . It grew relatively early, syn - to post-garnet growth, in a suprasolidus environment resulting in crystallographically determined oscillatory CL and trace element zoning. Grains record evidence of progressive deformation in the crystal plastic regime, where deformation is accommodated by dislocation glide, climb and deformation twinning. The dominant activated slip system is (100)<001> with minor component of <100>, while deformation twins show a ∼ 180° rotation around ∼<001> axis and a twin plane near (001). Grains appear to be impervious to deformation induced diffusion with all zoning remaining sharp despite crystal plastic deformation. Grains in direct contact with the Plag-Qtz-Ky domain show late modification of the CL and trace element signature suggesting melt-mediated interface-coupled dissolution-precipitation reaction. This modification resulted in crosscutting lobate high trace element regions and irregular rims with low Cr and V content. These rims show similar CL and trace element characteristics as Type 2 kyanite which are exclusively seen within the Plag-Qtz-Ky domain suggesting that Type 2 grains are cogenetic with Type 1 rims. Type 2 grains are finer grained than Type 1 grains and show near uniform CL and trace element distributions with rare oscillatory zoned and relatively higher Cr & V bright cores. Type 2 show either no or very localized internal deformation features. However, they exhibit a clear shape preferred orientation which coincides with a crystallographic preferred orientation where the longest shape axis is parallel to <001>. We propose that Type 2 kyanite grains underwent melt-present deformation by rigid body rotation in an externally derived melt with different trace element chemistry than the host rock. This melt thus interacted chemically by melt-mediated interface-coupled dissolution-precipitation reactions with the surrounding rocks forming the Type 1 rims. Our study shows detailed analysis of kyanite is an important tool for giving constraints on the deformation, P–T and melting history of high-grade metamorphic rocks and migmatites. • Two kyanite types defined by microstructure, paragenesis, EBSD, CL & trace elements. • T1 is from local partial melting, T2 is related to externally derived partial melt. • External melt modifies CL signal and trace elements in T1 kyanite. • Kyanite is resistant to crystal plastic deformation induced trace element diffusion. • Detailed investigation of kyanite yield independent process & evolution constraints.