Why Is Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering Insensitive to Liquid Water?

Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) is widely recognized as a remarkably powerful analytical technique that enables trace-level detection of organic molecules on a metal surface in aqueous systems with negligible spectral interference of water. This insensitivity of SERS to liquid water is violated in a restrictive manner under specific electrochemical conditions. However, the origin of such different SERS sensitivities to liquid water remains unclear. Here, we show that hydrogen-bond networks of water play a pivotal role in losing SERS enhancement for liquid water, and SERS detection of water requires local defects in the hydrogen-bond networks, which are formed around hydration shells of solute ions or on a polarized electrode surface. This work gives a new perspective on in situ SERS investigations in aqueous systems, including electrochemical and biological reactions.