The Binding of José Arcadio to the Fence: A Cognitive Ethnography of Situational Normativity of Moral Controversy in the LARP Game Cien Años
1. Abstract (2017; language revised 2026) This paper is both an ethnographic probe into an exotic setting of normativity – the fictional world enacted and embodied in a larp (a role-playing simulation) – and a theoretical essay on artificial intersubjectivity in role-playing simulations in general. Drawing on participant observation and semi-structured interviews, it analyses selected parts of the recent Czech larp Cien Años de Soledad (One Hundred Years of Solitude), inspired by Gabriel García Márquez's novel. The aim is to explore some aspects of the general problem of the situational normativity of moral behaviour, using the behaviour of the game's participants as an example. The focus is on situational micro-social relations between acting individuals and their environment. The research is inspired by cognitive approaches to culture, such as cognitive ethnography, ecological psychology and enactive cognition: situational normativity is understood as a property of a concrete instance of an embodied and enacted social environment. The core of the study is an analysis of one moral controversy from the game, from the point of view of its participants and of how the situation was constructed. The analytical axis is the conflict or synergy between the participants' personal normative attitudes ("real people") and the fictional normative order of the shared world ("characters"). By analysing the sources of behaviour in larp, the study explores the participants' situational normative attitudes and shows the interplay of factors on three levels of the situation (the reality of persons, players and characters). 2. About this record This record is an English translation of a paper first published in Czech: Tomáš Hampejs, "Přivazování José Arcadia k plotu: kognitivní etnografie situační normativity morální kontroverze v larpové hře Cien Años", AntropoWebzin 3–4/2017: 75–97 (ISSN 1801-8807; CC BY 3.0; http://www.antropoweb.cz/webzin/index.php/webzin/article/view/252). The translation was made by the author with AI assistance in 2026 and revised by the author. The translation is published under CC BY 4.0. Footnotes 1–100 are those of the original; seven further notes (marked *, †, ‡, §, ¶, **, ††), translation or author's notes of 2026, are new, as are passages in square brackets beginning "2026:" in footnotes 30, 70 and 95 (references to Komasová 2017). Four figures, one table and one box (Figures 1–4, Table 1, Box 1) were added in the English edition (2026) to summarize the analytical framework, the roles and the cases; they are based on the text and marked as additions, and where they go beyond it, this is stated. References to other papers of the same journal issue are linked. Quotations from García Márquez and from the game materials are translated from the Czech. The original Czech article is included in the record. 3. Summary for the English edition (2026) The paper treats larp (live action role-playing) as a technology of collective experience that can make a constructed social reality felt as autonomous – and thus as a possible ecologically valid "experiment" for the social sciences. It asks where the normativity of action in a larp situation comes from. It distinguishes three levels of the situation (persons, players and characters) and two layers, the prescriptive (the normative potential brought into the situation) and the enacted (its lived realization). Drawing on participant observation of two runs of the Czech larp Cien Años de Soledad (2016), which the author co-designed, and on interviews with twelve players, it follows one scripted scene in five versions: a son ties his mad father to a fence. The players had to improvise the legitimacy of the act. Their accounts show the three levels reinforcing one another (resonance) or colliding (dissonance), including cases in which a player's own relationship or moral sense interfered with the game; the player, as "the middle situational role", co-determines which of the two a charge becomes. The paper concludes that the "magic circle" of play is porous, that larp draws on non-special social-cognitive capacities, and that this kind of interference between enacted social orders is what we call conscience.
Authors
- Tomáš Hampejs (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9571-4748)
Institutions
- Masaryk University (CZ)
Publication Details
- Journal
- AntropoWeb (Katolícka univerzita v Ružomberku)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24418663
- Primary Topic
- Digital Games and Media
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00